Free guide
Trackers, active funds or your own process?
Figures are in pounds sterling. £1 ≈ US$1.31 ≈ €1.19 (20 November 2026).
At a dinner party, three guests are asked how they invest. The first says, “Index trackers, nothing else. You can’t beat the market.” The second says, “I pay a good manager to beat it for me.” The third says, “I run my own process.” Each looks at the others with mild pity. All three can be right, and all three can be wrong. It depends on what they pay, what they get and whether they stick to it.
This guide compares the three main ways to invest a larger portfolio: low-cost index trackers, actively managed funds, and running your own rules-based process. It looks at what the evidence says, what each really costs and when each makes sense.
Wherever you are in the world. The research below covers the US, UK and Europe. Trackers, active funds and self-directed investing are available in almost every market, through ISAs and SIPPs in the UK, 401(k)s and IRAs in the US, and their equivalents elsewhere.
Currency guide: £1 is about US$1.31 and about €1.19 (20 November 2026). The £750,000 portfolio in this guide is roughly $981,000 or €895,000.
“There is no free lunch in investing. But there are some very expensive ones.”Alpesh B Patel OBE
What the evidence says about active funds
S&P Dow Jones Indices publishes the SPIVA scorecards, which compare active funds with their benchmarks:
- US: in 2025, 79% of actively managed US large-cap funds underperformed the S&P 500. Over 15 years, the figure was about 90%.
- UK: in 2025, 89% of active funds investing in UK large and mid-sized companies underperformed their benchmark.
- Survival matters too. Morningstar’s research found that only about 13% of US large-cap active funds both survived and beat their average passive peer over the ten years to June 2026. Many funds simply close or merge.
That does not mean active management never works. Some areas, such as smaller companies and some bond markets, have historically given active managers a better chance. But picking the winners in advance is hard, and past winners often fail to repeat.
What each approach really costs
Cost is the one thing you know for certain in advance. Over long periods it compounds.
| £750,000 over 20 years at 6% a year before costs | Total yearly cost 0.15% | Total yearly cost 1.0% |
|---|---|---|
| Value after 20 years | about £2.34 million | about £1.99 million |
| Difference | about £350,000, from a cost gap of 0.85% a year | |
Illustration only: a constant return, no withdrawals, tax or platform fees. Real returns vary year to year.
Look at the total cost, not just the fund’s headline charge: platform fees, transaction costs, any adviser or discretionary manager fees, and currency charges. My guide What you really pay shows how to add them up.
The three approaches side by side
| Approach | Strengths | Weaknesses | Suits people who |
|---|---|---|---|
| Index trackers | Very low cost, broad diversification, simple | You own the whole market, including the most expensive and concentrated parts; no protection in falls; easy to abandon in a crash | Want simplicity and can sit through large falls without acting |
| Active funds | A professional makes the decisions; access to specialist areas | Higher costs; most lag their benchmark over time; manager changes | Value delegation and choose specialist areas carefully |
| Your own rules-based process | Low fund costs, full control, rules chosen by you based on research | Needs time, education, discipline and good tools; behavioural risk | Enjoy learning, have time, and will follow rules rather than headlines |
The limits of “just buy the index”
- Concentration. Global and US indices are now heavily weighted towards a handful of very large US technology companies. A “diversified” tracker can be more concentrated than people realise.
- No exit plan. A tracker has no rule for falls. The S&P 500 fell about 57% from 2007 to 2009; the investor’s own behaviour decides the outcome.
- Average by design. You get the market return, minus small costs. For many people that is a great outcome. Some want to apply research on factors such as value, quality and momentum. See is a global index tracker enough?
What “your own process” really means
Running your own money is not stock-tipping or trading on hunches. A real process has:
- Written buy rules based on evidence, such as valuation, growth, quality and trend.
- Written sell rules, decided in advance. See When to sell.
- Position-size and diversification limits.
- A review rhythm and a record of decisions.
- An honest benchmark: compare your results, after all costs, with a tracker of similar risk. If you consistently lag, a tracker may be the better choice.
Many people combine approaches: a tracker core with a smaller, rules-based portion they manage themselves. My guide DIY investing: what it really takes sets out the time and skills involved.
Before you switch approach
Changing approach often means moving money. Check in writing what you could lose before you sell or transfer.
Check these in writing first:
- Pensions: guaranteed annuity rates, defined benefit income, protected tax-free cash and exit fees. In the UK, safeguarded benefits worth more than £30,000 require regulated advice before transfer.
- Capital gains tax on selling funds outside ISAs and pensions: in the UK, gains above £3,000 are taxed at 18% or 24% for 2026/27. Consider transferring “in specie”.
- Time out of the market during a cash transfer.
- US: selling in a taxable account crystallises gains; most retirement account withdrawals before 59½ face a 10% additional tax.
What this taught me
I have invested in every one of these ways over the years. The biggest difference in outcomes I have seen has not been between trackers, active funds and self-managed portfolios. It has been between people with a clear approach they understood and stuck to, and people who switched between all three at the wrong moments.
What this taught me is that the best approach is the one whose costs you know and whose rules you will actually follow. So the question to take away is: do you know your total yearly cost, in pounds, and what you get for it?
Questions people ask
Do active funds beat index trackers?
Most do not over long periods. S&P’s SPIVA scorecard found 79% of US large-cap active funds lagged the S&P 500 in 2025 and about 90% over 15 years, and 89% of UK large and mid-cap active funds lagged in 2025. Some managers do outperform, but identifying them in advance is hard.
Are index trackers risk-free?
No. A tracker falls with the market: the S&P 500 fell about 57% in 2007 to 2009. Global and US indices are also heavily weighted towards a small number of very large companies.
How much do fund costs matter?
A great deal over long periods. In our illustration, £750,000 growing at 6% a year before costs for 20 years ends at about £2.34 million with 0.15% yearly costs and about £1.99 million with 1.0%.
Can I combine trackers and my own investing?
Yes. Many people hold a low-cost tracker core and manage a smaller portion with their own written rules, comparing that portion honestly with a tracker of similar risk.
What does running your own process involve?
Written buy and sell rules based on evidence, position-size and diversification limits, a review rhythm, a decision record and an honest benchmark. It needs time, education and discipline.
Is this financial advice?
No. This guide is education and information only. It is not a recommendation to buy or sell any investment.
Sources
- S&P Dow Jones Indices: SPIVA US Year-End 2025 (opens in a new tab)
- S&P Dow Jones Indices: SPIVA Europe Year-End 2025 (opens in a new tab)
- Morningstar: Active/Passive Barometer (opens in a new tab)
- Federal Reserve History: The Great Recession and its aftermath (opens in a new tab)
- GOV.UK: Capital Gains Tax rates and allowances (opens in a new tab)
- GOV.UK: Transferring your pension (opens in a new tab)
Important: this guide is education and information only. It is not financial advice or a personal recommendation, and it does not take your circumstances into account. The value of investments and pensions can fall as well as rise, and you may get back less than you put in. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results. Examples are illustrations, not predictions. If you are unsure what is right for you, speak to a regulated financial adviser.